This autumn kept coming back to one plain question: whether you can admit your own part in something.
It started small. A man sits on the floor of an animal shelter feeding treats through the bars to a dog that won’t stop barking, and the worker who left him there shrugs it off on his way out. lorica could have stopped at the shrug. Instead the essay ends with him owning a version of it himself: helping someone quickly, getting nervous, and pulling back just as he was being asked to stay. yod went looking for why the British only sing with an alibi (football, the third pint, a karaoke booth) and ended up in a German church, singing under his breath and unable to say whether that’s reverence or the same embarrassment. In Muddy Shoes, a grandmother shouts at a small boy for the mud on her good carpet, then can’t bring herself to move his shoes from the hall.
Then it got bigger. Debts of Empire starts at a statue in Windsor Great Park, with a grandmother saying this is what Britain is all about, and ends somewhere Britain would rather not go: Amritsar, the slave compensation paid to the owners, a famine that never made it into the story. A country that can’t say what it did can’t say what it’s doing either. Even then there’s no clean exit. He lets his overseas vote lapse and admits, in the same breath, that it isn’t an answer.
What’s odd is how little of it happens anywhere grand. A shelter. A kitchen. A hymn half-sung. The Thirty Hidden Years had already noticed that Christ spent ten years at a workbench for every one in public, and that the Gospels left the workbench blank. Brother Lawrence turned omelettes in a monastery kitchen for thirty years and called it prayer. Most of what anyone actually is gets settled in rooms like those, with nobody taking notes: whether you saw the person in front of you, and whether you told the truth about your part.
Countries fail at this the way people do, one unadmitted thing at a time. Which is mostly bad news. The small good news is where the repair starts. Not in Parliament. At the counter, the kitchen table, the pew.